Want to curb abalone poaching? Treat the cause
Drone video that showed poachers being caught misses the point
A drone video published on Facebook on 21 February reveals, in remarkable detail, the coordinated effort behind an abalone poaching operation in Pearly Beach, a holiday town on the Overberg coast. The clip has gone viral but fails to properly consider the root causes of South Africa’s abalone poaching problem: that access to wealth and marine resources remains deeply skewed along racial and class lines, leaving a gap that the poaching economy has expanded to fill.
The video shows nine divers kicking through kelp beds, repeatedly submerging to lever abalone from the reefs; they then return to shore to de-shell their catch. A pickup van collects them when they’re finished, followed by a crew of runners sent to collect their bags. Alerted by the drone pilots, the authorities pull up in time to confiscate the poached abalone (this will later be auctioned off by the fisheries department) while the runners scatter.
Scenes like these play out almost daily in places where there is abalone in South Africa. According to Traffic, a nonprofit organisation that monitors wildlife smuggling, poachers have harvested more than 40,000 tons of abalone here in the last two decades — nearly 20 times the entire legal catch. Chinese mafia groups control the trade in alliance with local street gangs, shipping the product to Hong Kong, where abalone has been a status symbol for more than 2,000 years. Dried South African abalone, the priciest mode of consumption, is worth over R45,000 per kg of flesh when converted back to wet weight.
Profits from these sales trickle down to local syndicates, sustaining a poaching epidemic that has depleted stocks while placing the commercial abalone fishery in jeopardy. This is the situation that the video — shot by two founders of a Cape Town drone startup, acting in their private capacity — sets out to address.
“Relentless Poaching is Ravaging the South African Coastline,” reads a caption early in the clip while a piano soundtrack plays. The lesson of the video, the viewer learns, is that “two guys and a drone were able to intercept a group of almost 20 individuals in just this one operation.”
At first blush this seems an effective strategy, the reach and resolution of a flying camera enabling two concerned citizens to disrupt a poaching hit that would otherwise very likely have succeeded. And it certainly could be, if linked to a wider management plan. Yet the drone clip records only inadvertent fragments of the bigger story that has allowed the abalone blackmarket to evolve.
After fetching the divers, the getaway van speeds down a coastal road, passing holiday homes with garages and sea views. The drone tracks the crew back to Eluxolweni, a small informal settlement outside Pearly Beach where dozens of poachers live in RDP houses and metal shacks. The disparity of these visual data is not remarked upon, though the producer, who happens to be a schoolfriend of mine, added a few lines about poverty and fishing rights to his original Facebook post when I challenged him on its lack of context. Still, the message is not clear enough, and I want to state it unequivocally: abalone poaching is a logical response to the inequality that still defines South Africa two decades after apartheid’s demise.
Since 2012, when I began researching a master’s thesis on the abalone trade, I have interviewed dozens of poachers from fishing communities across the Western Cape; at present I am working on a book with a diver whose family was evicted to the Cape Flats under the Group Areas Act. Settlements like Paternoster, Hangberg, Hawston and Gansbaai, where poaching is most firmly embedded, share long histories of dispossession, often stretching back generations before apartheid. Today they closely resemble each other: coastal ghettos split off from the mainstream economy though they are adjacent to wealthy white neighbourhoods, with protracted wrangles over fisheries reform still preventing most fishers from profitably accessing the sea.
In these areas, abalone poaching, while dangerous and criminalised, offers a rare opportunity to earn better money than South Africa’s society ordinarily dictates, even though that means entering an underworld economy intertwined with gangsterism and drugs.
Without this critical ingredient, it is extremely unlikely that abalone poaching would have exploded into the crisis it has become today.
Long before coloured fishing communities plugged into the abalone trade, poaching was largely the domain of renegade white men. The poaching stereotype in Cape Town in the 1980s was a sunburned student who dived perlemoen now and then for pocket money or to subsidise his university fees. (Port Elizabeth today has a large network of working-class white abalone poachers.) In other countries with wild abalone stocks, like Australia and the United States, poaching has been restricted to small bands of opportunists without widening into a systemic problem. Until we begin to grapple with the inheritance that has driven poaching into overdrive in South Africa we will fail to learn from our mistakes.
The video also encourages simplistic beliefs about criminality and provides fodder for racists and other misanthropes who say dreadful things under the guise of conservation. For example, here are some verbatim Facebook comments, some “liked” several times by other users:
“Great idea for the use of catching these Scumbags..Hope they get thrown to the Sharks for bait.”
“Use a the drone to drop a stun grenade on them in the water….will be the last time”
“Pity no great whites about.”
“Where’s a white shark when you need one?”
Just last September, in fact, a man in his 30s from the Eluxolweni township was killed by a great white shark, swimming three kilometres out to Dyer Island, a global cage-diving hotspot, to harvest abalone with a group of fellow divers. He was a Xhosa migrant from the Eastern Cape, among a new wave of marginalised South Africans to join the abalone trade. When I reported the story for GroundUp I saw many similar reactions on social media, claiming that the diver had got what he deserved.
Of course, it isn’t fair to hold content producers entirely responsible for how other people respond to their work, but in this instance the drone pilots — two young white men with the means to launch their own business — missed an opportunity to present a more balanced take. At the least their video could have dissuaded viewers from reaching for the sort of easy and myopic responses to illicit coping strategies that we so often see from South Africa’s privileged minority, who by and large still benefit from centuries of white supremacist rule.
For the many more viewers who care about the environment and do not hold hateful beliefs, the video could have provoked a conversation about what sustainability, in its widest sense, might actually look like in South Africa, taking its legacies of dispossession into account.
We need to be more honest about the circumstances, both historic and ongoing, that produce harmful economies like the abalone trade — not simply turn to drones as a solution. Nor should we uncritically praise the people who can afford to use them, even with the best intentions, for superficially fixing something that cuts much deeper.
Views expressed are not necessarily GroundUp’s.
© 2018 GroundUp.
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.
Under this logic, all crime committed by poor people is forgivable and can continue until “someone” solves inequality first. People have not been able to achieve it in thousands of years. Neither will a delusion that socialism can do it fare any better, more likely worse.
Is this not the crime that involves ruthless and heavily-armed gangs?
I don’t accept it. All crime should be dealt with immediately and with all tools available.
Abalone poaching is much the same as the theft of copper wire, with the distinct difference that it does not impact the same amount of people's daily lives. Yet the cause is exactly the same, and the remedy is exactly the same. The abalone poachers and the wire thieves are those at the 'bottom of the food chain' and if they are caught or die in the act then they are easily and quickly replaced. There are proven methodologies to get to the real perpetrators through tracing the goods to the final destination and cutting off the proverbial dragon's head.
It was presented to Johannesburg City Power in 2015 and to Prassa in CT recently, yet NO attempt has been made to implement the solution. Methinks the 'powers that be' are involved and are getting kickbacks from the syndicates, and the solution will identify this very soon in the process.
I'm the wife of a former poacher. We have four kids. He died while trying to provide for his family. Through poaching he got his qualifications as an offshore diver because his main goal was a real job, which he got but then unfortunately also got cancer and so we've lost everything we owned.
I couldn't go work because i had a disabled child to look after. Needless to say he returned to poaching because he had no choice. It ended in tragedy.
Now since we lost our home etc wellfare wanted our kids as well unless we can provide a home immediately.
Poaching kept my kids in school, the doctors' bills paid and fed us, but that was it. And people caused my children's dad to die. So I thank those people. I'm sure they thought they were a godsend for saving a snail.
I am new to the Analone coast. I have no property and no vested interest. I am keen to suggest a solution to poverty and natural resources such as Abalone.
May I humbly suggest that the way forward is quite simple, providing a workable plan is followed.
Firstly set up a training program for youth who are drawn from the families of Abalone poachers. The course should cover subjects that can utilize the candidates in policing, abalone tourism, sustainable abalone management. There are many examples of how poaching can be turned around to well managed projects that are profitable. In the 90’s I pioneered the Field Guides Association of Southern Africa (FAGASA). Today this is a respected organization that sets standards and employs hundreds of good men and women who if it were not for organizations like FAGASA would be left out of the booming eco tourism industry across Southern Africa. I would feel privileged to apply similar logistics, practical application and logistics to the benefit primarily of those brave skilled individuals who dive for this valuable resource. Let’s utilise the best of them to turn this around. I look forward to hearing from any interested parties. Especially the poachers. I have a high regard not for the law breaking but the potential to turn them around and into a legal profitable eco industry that we all can be proud of. I can be contacted by email at email@example.com.