Cape Town city centre tenants in tears as municipality auctions their homes
City says the Maynard Street homes are part of a de-proclaimed road scheme and are no longer required for municipal purposes
- An attorney at housing rights organisation, Ndifuna Ukwazi, is questioning the City of Cape Town’s decision to auction off its houses “in well-located areas” and “in the midst of a housing crisis”.
- One of two families who still live in City-owned Maynard Street homes, located near the city centre, say they have been there for 37 years and were taken aback last month by the notice to auction the property.
- The City says the homes form part of a de-proclaimed road scheme and are not required for municipal purposes anymore.
- The homes are set to be auctioned on 23 November.
Tamara-Kay McLachlan has been living in her late mother’s Maynard Street home for the last 37 years, but the property will soon be auctioned off by the City of Cape Town.
On 11 October, McLachlan said a notice was delivered to their home in Cape Town’s city centre which her elderly stepfather, who was home at the time, had signed on her behalf.
The “Notice of intention to sell city-owned property” stated that McLachlan’s tenancy and lease “might be terminated due to the City’s intention to sell the premises”.
McLachlan, angry and crying during our interview, asked, “Why us? There is literally a vacant house right next to us, why can’t they take that one? We have been living here for 37 years, how are we supposed to just pack up and leave? Where will we go?”.
“This was not even communicated to us prior to the delivery of the notice. I don’t understand what is happening … They are doing to us what was done to the people of District Six,” said McLachlan.
The City’s Mayco Member for Economic Growth, James Vos, confirmed that two properties in Maynard Street had been listed for auctioning on 23 November.
“The properties form part of a de-proclaimed road scheme and are not required for municipal purposes. A notice of intention to sell the property was hand delivered on 11 October and signed by the occupant,” said Vos.
Asked whether alternative accommodation would be offered by the city, Vos said alternative accommodation would be considered if it was required.
But McLachlan, who lives with three other family members, said she fears they will be relocated far from the city centre to communities like Pelican Park or Blikkiesdorp.
According to McLachlan, her mother was paying rates, taxes and rent at the property. But as of 2019, after not receiving any invoices, they stopped paying rent. Because of this, she said, their outstanding fees accumulated and according to a recent bill, the household’s rental arrears total is about R200,000.
Jonty Cogger, attorney at Ndifuna Ukwazi said they are concerned that public housing stock in well-located areas of the city is being sold.
“Once sold, it is lost to the market, available to the highest bidder, which inevitably excludes the 75% of Capetonians who earn less than R22,000 a month. It really does show that the City lacks long-term commitment to affordable housing,” he said.
Cogger questioned how the City could justify selling its own housing stock “in the midst of a housing crisis where 650,000 people are waiting for housing”.
In 2016, GroundUp first reported on tenants in Maynard Street who were faced with uncertainty after coming across a notice in local newspapers stating that their City-owned properties were “proposed for disposal”.
According to the City’s website, several prime properties aimed at “boosting the economy” are on offer as the city prepares to hold its last property auction of 2023.
McLachlan’s four bedroom home has already been put on an auction website, which provides details of the specifics of the home, with photographs and a countdown clock for when the auction would begin.
Why not offer the house to the occupants, giving them time to seek financial help if need be? The City is greedy for money instead of looking for other people's well-being. Instead of seeking to right all the wrongs of the past, they aggravate them.
This must stop. Please find a way to incorporate and integrate beautiful old homes like these into our city. We need a city that is inclusive and respectful!
To stop paying rates and taxes cause you don't get an invoice/statement is no reason. Let these people try and get a loan to pay these outstanding monies. Maybe they should try to make an agreement with the council?
It is unfortunate that the account of the Maynard Street occupants has fallen in arrears to the tune of approximately R200,000.
I am hopeful that the City of Cape Town can find a way to create a mechanism whereby we as citizens can carry a message to the world that this talented and resourceful municipality works towards a win-win outcome for both the City and the occupants, in the case of the Maynard Street residence.
With appreciation to the overall management and governance of the City of Cape Town.
Living in a house for such a long time and getting such a notice without being advised of it and not having the opportunity
to sit down to discuss it is not acceptable. My heart goes out to them.
© 2023 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.
We put an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. All analytics tools are solely on our servers. We do not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We do not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please do not delete the invisible pixel.